What's The Difference Between A Message And A Theme?

Love. War. Suffering. The circle of life. Good versus Evil.

What do you think of when you hear these words? If you imagine something large and dramatic, that's a good thing! Story-telling tackles these big ideas in creative ways.

The driving forces that help communicate the author's ideas to us are called messages and themes. They help us understand the bigger picture of a story. They help us connect to a story on an emotional and critical level. In short, messages and themes are a big reason why humans really love stories.

Look at the circle above.

Does everything inside of the circle belong in the same group?

"Colors" is the category for this group, not a part of the group. Everything else inside in the circle, however, is part of the group. They are examples of colors!

That's how we should look at the difference between theme and message.

Photo by Greg Rakozy on Unsplash

What is a theme in a story?

Simply put, a theme is a big idea in a story. It's a big idea because it is universal, meaning it applies to everyone, and it's abstract. Something that's abstract means that it can't be held or touch. For example, something huge like "love" is universal. Love can take many forms, but the idea of love is a concept. Everyone in the world at some point can relate to the idea of love.

To recap: if it's big, abstract, and universal, we've got a theme.

Photo by michael schaffler on Unsplash

What is a message in a story?

A message is an example of a big idea, or the theme, of a story. Recall the above example: love can take many forms. The form that love takes in a story is the message.

Messages are specific to the story, related only to the characters, and are concrete. If you're reading a story about two teenagers falling in love, we can relate to the idea of love but we can't relate to the specific love one character feels for another. Why? We're not them!

Photo by Melissa Askew on Unsplash

Let's look at an example

This Side of Paradise by F. Scott Fitzgerald

• Young man conformed to society

• Finds conformity meaningless

• Growing up years after the World War

• Is comforted by knowing himself and hopes for a generation not so lost as his

The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger

• Young man isolated by society

• Isolation leads to loneliness and cynicism

• Growing up years after the World War

• Marches to the beat of his own drum, feeling like he is the only sane person left of his generation

Both stories are about young men in a lost generation after a major world war. Both of these men are finding their place in society and figuring out their identity.

We can say that the big ideas in these stories are about finding oneself and growing up as an adult. Those big, abstract, and universal concepts are the themesof the stories. But the characters and their stories are very different. What they go through are concrete, specific situations that help communicate the themes. Those situations are messages.

Theme

• a big idea or group of ideas

• an abstract concept that only exists as an idea

• a universal idea or group of ideas that everyone in the world can relate to

Message

• a specific example of the theme of the story

• related to the characters and actions of the story

• concrete forms of an idea

  

Stories without messages won't have a purpose or an idea to deliver. Stories without themes won't be able to connect to our real-world or communicate larger issues to us.

Think about some stories that you absolutely love. What are your favorite messages and themes?